Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Guest Post: Women on Medicaid Are Being Forgotten in Stupak Outrage


Guest post by Danine Spencer. Originally posted at danine.net.

On Saturday night, my joy and relief at the health care reform bill being passed in the House of Representatives was quickly wiped out by the fury being expressed on Twitter and elsewhere by feminists and progressives over the Stupak amendment. According to the Feminist Majority Foundation, the amendment “bans abortion coverage even if women pay for it with their own money in the public option or private plans in the insurance exchange.”

This is obviously a big deal. In a press release, FMF’s president Ellie Smeal said:

“Millions of poor and middle class women will be denied abortion coverage. Millions more may lose abortion coverage because currently some 85% of private plans now have such coverage.”

I agree the Stupak amendment is terribly, terribly wrong. It is, as Ms. Smeal said, “an unacceptable, giant step backward for women.” Still, abortion cannot be allowed to derail health care reform. This is far too important to me and millions of other women – and men. Health care reform is about life and death. Out-of-control premiums and medical bills are forcing families to choose between buying groceries for their kids, paying the mortgage or obtaining life-saving medical treatment and prescription drugs.

Health care reform is not about abortion. Bart Stupak and the other “pro-life” members of Congress should be ashamed of themselves for hijacking what may be the most important piece of legislation of our time. This is truly a matter of life and death.

Abortion cannot be allowed to derail health care reform. Still, there is another issue that has been overlooked in the outrage over the Stupak amendment. According to the Kaiser Foundation, 9.5 million women are currently on Medicaid. The federal standard for Medicaid requires abortion coverage only in situations where the mother’s life is in danger or in the case of rape or incest. Thirty-two states and the District of Columbia only provide this level of coverage while seventeen states exceed federal requirements, funding “all or most medically necessary abortions”.

If abortion doesn’t derail the bill and we actually get health care reform passed, Medicaid’s ranks will expand to include 150% of the Federal Poverty Level, including millions more women.

What about poor women? Don’t we deserve abortion coverage as part of our reproductive rights? Where is the outrage for us? It seems like the feminist movement has simply forgotten about the poorest and sickest of women, those who are most likely to be in need of abortion services. Indeed, many women enroll in Medicaid because they are pregnant and uninsured. Our society has created a safety net for low-income women when they get pregnant but that safety net is full of knots and hard to break free of.

Medicaid’s income limits keep women mired in poverty. StateHealthFacts.org reports that 52.3% of non-elderly families receiving Medicaid have at least one full-time worker, which means that worker is working full-time but doesn’t have health insurance through their job. In order to keep their Medicaid, they cannot earn more than the FPL eligibility limits for their state. If they do earn more than the limits, they risk losing their health insurance.

Furthermore, 47.8% of the non-elderly on Medicaid work part-time or not at all. These people are not eligible for employer-sponsored plans and will probably be unable to afford any plans in the new insurance exchange. They will be stuck on Medicaid. Without abortion coverage.

It has been extremely frustrating and infuriating to watch the uproar over the Stupak amendment. It feels like the feminist movement has forgotten about the poor, sick and disabled women who are on Medicaid and only have access to abortion services under the Hyde Amendment.

Those of us on Medicaid deserve the same reproductive rights that everyone else is entitled to. We are not second-class citizens. We’re women.

DC Same-Sex Marriage Law, Just a Formality?

Currently being drafted in D.C Council's Committee on Public Safety is Bill 18-482. What is so special about that Bill (that causes me to jig in my seat) you might ask? It is a bill circulating that argues, "marriage equality already exists in the city, and a law legalizing it isn't much more than a formality" according to DCist.

The bill recognizes that NOWHERE in the constitution does it define marriage as a union only between a woman and man. It cites several other laws and initiatives that have been drafted and used in the DC area dating back from 1992 that worked to use gender neutral language, allowing more rights to same-sex couples. Having the right to marry is more than just a piece of paper binding two people together. Marriage constitutes federal benefits and protections, like estate taxes, hospital visitation, Medicaid and more. All of which are things civil unions and domestic partnerships cannot. The right to marry is simply granting people access to the same benefits and protections that other people already legally have.

The bill is expected to be marked up today and ready for a council vote on December 1st. Keep your fingers and toes crossed people, I know those of us at Feminist Majority Foundation sure are!

Picture Credit: o'holy sweet cakes on flickr.com

Coming soon (we hope!): Same Sex Marriage in New York

Hey, remember that time the sh*t hit the fan and the New York State Senate went crazy? Well they now have a chance to redeem themselves!

The State Senate is convening at noon today for a special session to vote on a long-awaited marriage equality bill. The outcome of the vote is uncertain, with activists on both sides proclaiming confidence that their side will prevail.

New Yorkers, this is where you come in--let your State Senator know that all people deserve the right to marry.

Obama Takes a Stab at Stupak

Throughout this Stupak whirlwind, we've been awaiting to publicly address where he stands on the legislation.

Last night, on ABC news, the President defended the rights of 50% of the American population, as well as put the debate in big picture terms, by saying:

“I laid out a very simple principle, which is this is a health care bill, not an abortion bill...And we're not looking to change what is the principle that has been in place for a very long time, which is federal dollars are not used to subsidize abortions...I want to make sure that the provision that emerges meets that test that we are not in some way sneaking in funding for abortions, but, on the other hand, that we're not restricting women's insurance choices.”

Here, Obama points out that Health Care Reform should be just that, and not be used as a means to sneak in conservative slashes to reproductive rights. Thank you, President Obama!! You are what a feminist looks like!

photo credit: vmarinelli on flickr.com

Monday, November 9, 2009

Don’t Tell me Abortion isn’t Basic health care.

On Halloween of this year, Robin Marty had an “abortion.” (RH Reality Check)

Robin Marty isn't a teenager who forgot to use a condom, or a young college woman who can't "deal" with having a child, the stereotypes many anti-choicers want you to believe. She was a soon to be second time mother, until she found out that the fetus she had been carrying for 12 weeks had died at just 8 weeks old. Faced with a potential medical emergency, Marty was given three options. The first, wait for a miscarriage, which her doctor said didn’t look to occur anytime soon, and, if left for too long, the fetus could cause a fatal infection. Her second option was to have a chemical abortion, which, because of how far along she was, would not be 'complete' and would would need to be followed up with a D&C (Dilation & Curettage). The third and final option was to have a D&C, the procedure that is referred to both medically and in political discourse as an abortion.

Marty went with the third option as it was in the best interest for her, her family, and any future children she may have (in addition to infection, waiting for a miscarriage could potentially leave Marty infertile.) Unlike many Americans, she was fortunate enough to have a private health insurance plan that would cover the procedure, although Marty would have to pay the maximum out-of-pocket expense of $1,500. Why does Marty's case matter to today's health care debate?

Before we get in to the politics, let's recap real quick to make sure we're on the same page. Robin Marty had an abortion to remove an already dead fetus from her uterus that, had it not been removed, could have caused infertility or a fatal infection. This procedure was necessary for not only her health, but her life and the well-being of her family.

Ok, so here we go.

Under the Stupak Amendment of the House Health Care Bill, Robin Marty could potentially be denied access to this procedure under her health insurance, regardless of whether or not it was under the public option or through a private insurance company; regardless of the potentially life-saving nature of the procedure. Currently, Marty's insurance doesn't have the option to opt-out of covering the procedure and therefore had to cover it; the Stupak Amendment would allow private insurers, like Marty's, to opt out of covering what is medically termed an abortion, leaving women like Robin Marty to cover the costs herself, or risk potentially fatal consequences.

Because abortion is such a broad term, there is no differentiation between the abortion of a live fetus versus one that has already died. So women like Robin Marty, whose body doesn’t quite pick up on the fact that it is no longer pregnant, would not be able to receive the life saving procedure unless they could afford the more than $1,500 in health care costs, assuming they would be able to find a provider.

Abortion is basic health care; in many cases, it is an instance of life and death for the mother. The abortions that are covered by insurance companies are rarely, if at all, elective. Those covered by insurance companies are only those performed in attempt to save the life or preserve the health of the mother.

Robyn Marty would have suffered serious health consequences and possible death had she not gotten this abortion; don't tell me that abortion isn't basic health insurance, Stupak. Instead, tell me why, under this “comprehensive” health care bill that is attempting to bring basic health care to 96 million + Americans, women still must be denied? A health care bill that does not cover basic, reproductive health care for women does not sound "comprehensive" to me.


photo credit: opendemocracy from Flickr

I Object to the Objection!

Do we take health care seriously? More specifically, do we take WOMEN's health care seriously?

Evidently, women's health is such an important issue that key members of Congress are directly and personally threatened by it.

Watch and be amazed...


Reactions?

Stupak is Whack

30 feminists descended on Capitol Hill today to protest the Stupak amendment. I was one of them.

The rally, sponsored by NOW, drew feminists from groups like the Feminist Majority Foundation, Southeast Asia Resource Action Center, and the National Women's Law Center.

We met in front of the Dirksen Senate Office Building, carrying signs that said "Keep Ur Stupak Off My Body," "Stupak is Whack!," and "Healthcare for All!" We were promptly greeted by Randall Terry of Operation Rescue and his anti-choice buddies. They followed us around, shouting "Abortion is murder!" through their megaphones.

Oddly enough, we got serenaded by Randall in a Grim Reaper costume. His lyrics bordered on sexual harassment and were pretty demeaning. "Don't worry ladies, I want all your children." "Girls, girls, keep abortion going." Oh well, religious nutjobs going out of their way to put you down is a sign that you're doing something right.

We did two laps around the office building before we were asked to leave by Capitol Police. You can only do so much with an impromptu protest and no permit.

I hope these protests pick up in size. We need our Congressfolk to kill this amendment!


Is Separate Ever Equal?: Nickelodeon Gives Its Take

"If you don't know how to cope with a dude that's, like, annoying you, when you grow up, boys will be bugging you all the time" -wise words from a frustrated student, nick news

Blast from the past! This morning, I came across an email entitled "Linda Ellerbee and gender-segregation." For those of you who may have forgotten Linda Ellerbee is the host of Nick News, the issue-based news program geared towards Nickelodeon's audiences (Oh nerdy childhood memories of specials like "Kids Pick the President" *sigh.*)

With one click of a mouse, I was watching Linda Ellerbee and her crew of tiny tots duke out single-sex vs. co-ed education, a topic bothering education advocates since Bush's 2006 weakening of Title IX/acceptance of voluntary separate, but equal education. (Nick news should NOT be hitting these issues before Obama, btw!)

Throughout the show, kids and experts alike try to argue that gender differences are significant enough to affect the learning process. Arguments included "girls require cooperative environments and boys need competition," "girls prefer to be taught as if they're being comfortably parented, while boys prefer the military, drill-Sergent style" and "boys like to sprawl out around the classroom, while girls prefer to sit properly."

As someone who is passionate about giving all children the opportunity to live up to their highest potential, I firmly believe in doing whatever it takes to get kids to the top (just not this.) Aside from rumors that "separate, but equal" national policies haven't always worked out for this country, here's some other reasons why I am not a fan of single-sex ed:

*Single sex education only exaggerates gender stereotypes (and puts emphasis on gender differences, as opposed to what's in common.) While teaching, I've seen a range of personalities in both boys and girls. Not all boys prefer competition, not all girls prefer cooperation. There are times that both both boys should play up each characteristic, therefore; everyone should be taught and expected to do both well.

*There is not any proof that single-sex education produces better results. Often schools that practice sex-segregation have other factors working in their favor (privately funded, smaller class sizes, more master teachers, computers in every room, parental-involvement programs, etc...)

*"Distraction" is an easy, but inaccurate excuse. No matter the company around them, younger boys and girls will find subjects to distract them (popularity, sports, tv, etc...) Women and men will need to interact in the work place and (for the better or worse) hormones do not disappear after college. That already awkward time in middle school/high school is a great time for learning about relationships without drastic professional consequences.

*Research show no difference in how boys and girls learn and that teaching the two differently even has negative consequences. Teaching with two separate learning style means that information and skills taught can never be exactly the same. It may even be as simple as boys taking more verbal exams, while girls becoming more proficient in written testing. Small as this may seem, the job market is competitive and future employers will hold everyone to the same skill-set expectations.

FMF Press Release on Stupak Amendment


House Passes Historic Health Reform
Women’s Rights Suffers Major Defeat in Passage of Stupak Amendment


The House passed the historic Affordable Health Care Act (HR3962) by a narrow margin (220-215) with major gains for women including eliminating gender rating in insurance prices, banning pre-existing conditions, capping out of pocket expenses, expanding Medicaid to include individuals at 150% of the federal poverty level, improving Medicare by closing the donut hole on prescription drug coverage, no charge for preventive care, and stopping the practice of dropping coverage or capping coverage of sick people. Important provisions that advance the health needs of LGBT people were also included in the Act. Unequal taxation of domestic partner benefits was eliminated.

Women’s rights advocates, however, were delivered a major defeat Saturday night by passage of the outrageously restrictive anti-abortion Stupak amendment to the Affordable Health Care for America Act (HR 3962) by a 240-194 vote of the House of Representatives. The amendment, co-sponsored by Bart Stupak (D-MI), Joe Pitts (R-PA), Brad Ellsworth (D-IN), Dan Lipinski (D-IL), and Kathy Dahlkemper (D-PA), bans abortion coverage for women in both the public option and private insurance. Under the guise of no federal funding for abortion in so-called keeping with Hyde Amendment restrictions, the Stupak Amendment goes way beyond Hyde. This amendment bans abortion coverage even if women pay for it with their own money in the public option or private plans in the insurance exchange.

“This is an outrageous denial of choice to women dictated by the National Conference of Catholic Bishops and their army of lobbyists,” said Eleanor Smeal, President of the Feminist Majority. “Millions of poor and middle class women will be denied abortion coverage. Millions more may lose abortion coverage because currently some 85% of private plans now have such coverage. The Stupak amendment far from being abortion neutral is an unacceptable, giant step backward for women.”

The fight is far from over. Many pro choice legislators and groups, who were reluctantly willing to compromise on the Capps amendment included in the Act, are now determined to strip the Stupak amendment from the Act before it is finally approved by Congress and signed by the president. The Capps amendment provided that no federal funds would be used for abortion. It also provided that in the insurance exchange there would be at least one option that would include abortion coverage and at least one that would not at every premium level for an individual or small business to purchase with their own dollars. The anti abortion forces took advantage of a close House vote on passage of the Affordable Health Care for Americans Act this weekend by Stupak and some 30 legislators pledging they would not vote for final passage unless their total ban on abortion coverage amendment received a floor vote. The Act was only approved by a slim 220-215 ultimately, with Stupak and 20 other members of Congress who both voted for the amendment, voting for the Act.

“Pro-choice forces feel they have been had and are willing and able to step up pressure as the Act proceeds to the Senate for action, then to a House/Senate conference committee, and back to both the Senate and House for final approval before the President signs it into law,” observed Smeal. “There are many more pro-choice Democrats than anti-abortion ones. The question must be answered if the Democrats are more willing to dance to the tune of the Catholic bishops or to listen to its overwhelming constituency of pro-choice women. We must stop every major act being used as a vehicle to cut back reproductive rights. Young women’s lives cannot continue to be a political football. This historic Act must be freed of abortion politics and that is what the pro-choice forces tried to do.”

CALLING ALL DC FEMINISTS: Rally Today in Support of Pro-Choice Health Care Reform!

-- Please Forward This Message Widely --

Dear NOW Members and pro-choice allies,

We MUST protect our rights! We NEED you on the streets! NOW! After a
backroom deal late Friday night, and a floor vote late Saturday night,
the House has accepted restrictions on abortion that go far beyond
the despicable Hyde Amendment, which has denied federal funding of abortion
since 1976. We must denounce the House's passage of the Stupak Amendment.

We can not allow the Senate to incorporate similar language in its own
bill.

For more information, please see the following statement from our President
Terry O Neill:
http://www.now.org/press/11-09/11-08.html

Please join together with NOW activists over the lunch hour tomorrow to make
sure our Senators know women are watching. We will rally on the sidewalks
for all women, because we have been left out of the House health care bill.

Date: Monday, November 9
Time: 12 p.m. (noon)
Location: Meet at the corner of Constitution and Delaware
Walking a loop around Russell, Dirksen and Hart Senate Office Buildings
Bring: Cameras, NOW Rounds (we will bring some for those who need them)
Homemade signs* (please remember to write on both sides of the signs)

We will bring additional signs for those who need them.

Thank you,
Erin
Erin Matson
Action Vice President
National Organization for Women
(202) 628-8669
www.now.org

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Western Regional Feminist Campus Leadership Conference is a Success!

The Western Regional Feminist Campus Leadership Conference was held at Santa Monica College in Los Angeles, CA on November 6 & 7th. Over 176 people from the Western States from 35 campuses were in attendance.

Speakers included Dolores Huerta, Councilwoman Jan Perry, Feminist Majority Foundation’s Kathy Spillar, and numerous student leaders. Many came to our SpeakOUT rally to share their thoughts on feminist issues. We had 8 workshops that focused on violence against women, fake clinics, global women’s rights, LGBTQ rights, women of color, anti-abortion extremism, trafficking, family planning, sustainable development, and femicide. It was a great success! Thank you for all who came and participated in the conference!

Friday, November 6, 2009

HRC loves FMF, nbd.

Translation: Hillary Rodham Clinton loves Feminist Majority Foundation, No Big Deal


Nolimits.org, a non-partisan, non-political organization aimed at bringing the public into the political process, held their first annual Public Policy Conference at the Ronald Reagan building. Speakers included Congressman Barney Frank (his sister Ann Lewis is a founder of No Limits), White House Deputy Chief of Staff Jim Messina and our extraordinary Secretary of State, Hillary Rodham Clinton.

Thanks to our Political Director, Alice Cohan, ten of us, including all the campus organizers and five interns, had the unbelievable opportunity to hear Sec. Hillary Clinton’s speech. Clinton emphasized her commitment to improving the rights of women, children, and families around the world while; Clinton claimed her main motivation throughout her political career has been to enable every child to grow up and “reach their god-given potential.” Clinton was adamant that ‘their’ issues and ‘our’ issues are the same; there is no us vs. them anymore, just us.

You may not know the father of two in Kansas who will be receiving your tax dollars to pay for his cancer treatment, and you may not know the pregnant woman in the Congo who will finally receive prenatal care. But in making these changes and reaching out to these people, we are making America a better place, and the world a better place. I could not agree with her more. Oh right, and then she totally gave a shout out to Feminist Majority, woot woot!

It was fitting for Hillary Clinton to speak at this event. Not only does No Limits stand for much of the same issues she does herself, but no limits is directly aligned with one of Clinton’s most central beliefs: “With our ingenuity, innovative spirit and creativity, there are no limits to what is possible in America.”
Amen sister!


Photo credit: nrbelex from flickr

US Infant Mortality Ranks High Amongst Developed Nations

In 1960, The US ranked 12th in prevention infant mortality. In 2005, it ranked 30th. So what drove the decline in status?

The US Department of Health and Human Services Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recently released a study connectiong the USA's relatively high infant mortality rate (considering its status as a "developed nation") to its similarly relatively high premature birth rate. In a review of the study, the Women's Health Policy Report showed pointed out that the US premature birth rate was about twice the premature birth rate of Sweden--12.4 percent to 6.3 percent. The study does show that once born premature, the US does generally better at keeping the babies alive, but that we're not doing a very good job in preventing babies from coming out early.

So why are so many of the births in this country pre-mature and risky?

Because we're not taking care of our low-income pregnant women, who are diproportionately giving birth prematurely. The highest infant mortality rates occurred amongst American Indian, Alaska native, non-hispanic black, and Puerto Rican women. The study noted that the US doesn't guarantee pre-natal care, implying that this plays a role in the high infant mortality rate.

Other reasons the study cited as contributing to the high infant mortality rate were increased occurence of C-sections, increased use of fertility treatments (*cough* Octo-mom *cough* ), drug and alcohol use and illness.

The reasons to show that women need comprehensive health care reform just keep piling up, don't they?

Photo Credit: kqedquest on flickr.com

Hartzveytik! A Heartbreak Survival Society Social

BUST Magazine is throwing an amazing event in NYC. It's going to have the Shondes and Veganomicon co-author Terry Hope Romero!!! I'm excited! Here's the event info:

Hartzveytik! A Heartbreak Survival Society Social
Sponsored by BUST Magazine

Join the Heartbreak Survival Society for an extraordinary evening of music and mayhem! You'll laugh; you'll cry; you'll wonder; you'll revel and dance with the lovelorn of New York City. If you've ever had your heart broken, this is the fall ball you can't miss.

Hear!
The breathtaking music of Soft Power (http://www.myspace.com/softpowerband w/ Mary Timony)
The Shondes (http://www.myspace.com/theshondes)
Royal Pink (http://www.myspace.com/royalpinkrocks)
The Low & The Lonesome(http://www.myspace.com//thelowandthelonesome)!

Plus Special Guests!
Franz Nicolay (The Hold Steady)!
Ariel Schrag (cartoonist, L Word writer)
Your illustrious MC, Ronica!
And more!

Sponsored by:
Bust Magazine! Free issues of Bust at the event!

See!
The world's tiniest craft fair! Eye candy and mind-boggling merchandise!

Taste!
Vegan heartbreak treats!
from Terry Hope Romero (co-author Veganomicon. Vegan Cupcakes Take Over the World & Vegan Cookies Invade Your Cookie Jar)

Win!
Celebrity heartbreak mixtapes! Pickled things! Fashion goodies!
Raffle ticket $ to benefit the Sylvia Rivera Law Project (http://www.srlp.org)

Dance!
Dance party featuring DJ Tikka Masala and DJ Shomi Noise of That's My Jam

For more info: http://spsounds.com
Buy tickets here and now! http://www.ticketweb.com/t3/sale/SaleEventDetail?dispatch=loadSelectionData&eventId=2541004

Photo courtesy of http://www.flickr.com/photos/kainet

Google's Got Gender Issues

I am not big on Halloween...I am, I just don't do the make up and the crazy costumes. I like to keep things simple and clever. So this year, I went as Google. With my homemade t-shirt that said "Search me" (take that all you 'sexy' cops!) and Google across my chest...I took to the streets, trick or treating of course.

Thanks to Feminist Law Professors, I came across this little 'experiment,' and, I must say, RIP Google dignity. I tried to give you a good name, and this is how you repay me?!?

I dare you, go to Google.com and type in "women should" and *don't click search* wait for the drop down of possible related searches...you'll be surprised at what you might find...


Women Should..."not be in combat"
Women Should..."stay at home"
Women Should..."be silent in church"
Women Should..."not wear pants"
women should..."not preach"
and let us not forget that women should..."wear white like all other domestic appliances"

Ay yi yi!